Claire was still spiraling over her inability to write anything down.45Please respect copyright.PENANAWYnmniLfpT
— That as-soon-as-you-write-it-it-disappears kind of frustration twisted in her chest like the early warning of a vomit you know has nowhere to go.
Then someone walked in.
A man. In uniform.45Please respect copyright.PENANAixZLAOLJOT
Not one she recognized.
— Claire flinched. Literally flinched.45Please respect copyright.PENANAl1Cx1ikNNq
Not the kind of reflex you have when a customer walks in.45Please respect copyright.PENANAO3bsMv55ay
This was different.45Please respect copyright.PENANAm9xJIKcjJs
This was a variable.
Her eyes shot to the clock.45Please respect copyright.PENANA3IF467eFDI
The time was right.45Please respect copyright.PENANA1rrHuCvm0K
But the man was wrong.
He was young.45Please respect copyright.PENANAbm81AzB43h
Blue-eyed. Smiling. Polished.45Please respect copyright.PENANAtxOV73No1U
Not like the usual middle-aged officers whose uniforms barely survived the war against their beer bellies.
— This wasn’t just unfamiliar.45Please respect copyright.PENANAGAU6HrL6X7
It was too new.45Please respect copyright.PENANAqRufO4dvpP
Too “present.”45Please respect copyright.PENANAqTIOMxFUIT
His movements didn’t carry yesterday’s echo.45Please respect copyright.PENANAaLxql9ec17
Nothing about him felt pre-recorded.
He was... real.
He walked to the counter, removed his cap, and smiled.45Please respect copyright.PENANAuykGpsAsVa
“Hi, you’re Claire, right? Kyle said the bagels would be out late today. Sent me to pick up the order.”
— Even his voice had warmth.45Please respect copyright.PENANAvLEazxbCM8
Like morning sunlight just reaching a glass of water.
Claire nodded and reached for a paper bag.45Please respect copyright.PENANAQFpUx3aPoe
— Her thoughts still looping: He’s not in my memory.45Please respect copyright.PENANAWXrKUKlYMT
Not some cop’s kid. Not a familiar blur from the past.45Please respect copyright.PENANAdCMDAGIkzA
He was a new puzzle piece—and this world wasn’t supposed to have any left.
As she packed the bagels, the blue-eyed officer glanced at the newspaper on the counter—the same old Nightwing photo.
The one with the annoyingly cheerful mid-air leap.45Please respect copyright.PENANACWK5z4m6Og
And yes.45Please respect copyright.PENANArtKX9PE7GK
That shot.45Please respect copyright.PENANAjsR1wuBlKG
That damn ass.
The officer didn’t laugh.45Please respect copyright.PENANAGbM3uewhZF
Didn’t snort like Kyle.45Please respect copyright.PENANAHlXdFRW1vM
Didn’t mutter “that kid again.”
He just looked.45Please respect copyright.PENANArCxceLtKUD
Silent.45Please respect copyright.PENANAr1PGQdr105
One eyebrow twitching—like he was thinking.45Please respect copyright.PENANA6QTT1JNiUZ
Or recognizing something.
Claire stepped out from behind the counter and handed him the bag.
Her gaze flicked to the paper as she did, tracing the direction he had just been looking.45Please respect copyright.PENANALGi9Ud51EP
She knew he caught that glance.
She didn’t explain.45Please respect copyright.PENANAdjL5BL4vy4
Didn’t ask.45Please respect copyright.PENANAxMVPsxHrrd
Didn’t care what this bright-eyed stranger thought of Nightwing’s overexposed butt.
“Here’s your bagels,” she said flatly.45Please respect copyright.PENANAGPj9HutMA9
It could’ve been “good morning” for all the emotion she gave it.
He nodded, smiled a little awkwardly. “Thanks.”
Then he paused.45Please respect copyright.PENANA2ovEwZj9wD
“Hey… uh. Just wondering. What do you think of Nightwing? I mean, we work with him a lot. Curious what people think.”
Claire looked at him.45Please respect copyright.PENANAV1ANjPMd2b
Just once.45Please respect copyright.PENANAyxiW2jaIDa
Then turned away.
— Didn’t offer a smirk.45Please respect copyright.PENANAthFsM8H6rl
Didn’t offer a sigh.45Please respect copyright.PENANAYihbJUYIDF
Just rolled her eyes with the weariness of someone who’s rolled them way too many times this week.
The officer would later swear he heard her mumble as she turned:
“Hope his ass falls off.”
He blinked.
Not because it was shocking.45Please respect copyright.PENANAMboSZgH1d2
But because she said it so effortlessly.45Please respect copyright.PENANAO98N4SyRxm
So plainly.45Please respect copyright.PENANA45Uxn0vmq7
Like she was saying “we’re out of cat food.”
He didn’t know whether to laugh or nod.45Please respect copyright.PENANAJ9stRfnkH6
So he just held the bag a little tighter.
She was still fretting over the whole “can’t-write-anything-down” thing—45Please respect copyright.PENANAoWKSJWZF3Y
— That nausea-without-an-exit feeling sloshing in her chest, like a gag reflex that never gets to finish.
45Please respect copyright.PENANA4GImIG7MWw
Claire figured if you wanted to fix a problem, you'd better look it in the face.45Please respect copyright.PENANAFlhJTZLjc5
Avoidance didn’t make you miss the big picture—it made you miss the details.45Please respect copyright.PENANAjvYo1bhGx0
This wasn’t a movie. No last-minute plot armor. No chosen one moment. If she was going to survive this, she had to do it herself.
She couldn’t write things down.45Please respect copyright.PENANAkdXEhLhWCh
So she’d memorize them instead.45Please respect copyright.PENANARoUGQVkXX4
If this place erased every mark she left, then her memory would be the map.45Please respect copyright.PENANAul8u2PcFxn
That was the deal—quietly made, silently accepted.
Tonight, Claire decided to stay up.45Please respect copyright.PENANAlk3wviQAW0
Normally, she was in bed by ten. Sharp.45Please respect copyright.PENANAVIyVNfZ2zB
Not for beauty sleep. Not because she had to.45Please respect copyright.PENANABxOJ4MaYiD
But because being awake at night had always meant danger.45Please respect copyright.PENANAQj6Ef67QCn
Losing control. Going missing.
That was the Gotham in her talking.45Please respect copyright.PENANAVC3kynwmbO
Nighttime wasn’t a vibe—it was a warning.45Please respect copyright.PENANAbl2dQECEpp
The city didn’t teach you that.45Please respect copyright.PENANALdqeARKC5A
It branded it into your bones.
She was only in Blüdhaven because of her aunt’s inheritance.45Please respect copyright.PENANAbxGRnJDo7m
Not that this city was gentle. But compared to Gotham?45Please respect copyright.PENANARorkT4xxfm
Blüdhaven was a cupcake shop with a flickering sign.
Tonight, Claire made her own coffee.45Please respect copyright.PENANAHIA2hbDyHi
The clock said 11:00 PM.45Please respect copyright.PENANA9TPZ8PSAI9
The calendar next to her had tomorrow’s date already circled.45Please respect copyright.PENANAyWZrkFsYLD
Usually, she only circled the date when she sold out her bagels.45Please respect copyright.PENANA2ms34UAB7G
It was her little ritual—write the number sold, feel a tiny sense of victory.
But tonight she circled it early.45Please respect copyright.PENANAlOYDOaPCXR
Like a declaration:45Please respect copyright.PENANA5SWCuCfZbq
I’m still awake on this day. I’m still alive on this day.
She had no idea when the loop would reset.45Please respect copyright.PENANAFoeYmdxFAk
Midnight? Three in the morning?45Please respect copyright.PENANA9Q6ukwO22Y
Maybe the second she fell asleep?45Please respect copyright.PENANAeweVkZgb8k
Come to think of it, she’d never seen a “real” end to the day.45Please respect copyright.PENANAloduJbKHHw
Time always hit reset in the dark.45Please respect copyright.PENANAdQbJrKZhEH
Like someone pressed a button in her sleep.
Claire stared off into space.
45Please respect copyright.PENANACQM8UPsTMk
Then came a sound.45Please respect copyright.PENANA58xkUkixxh
From the balcony.
Claire looked up.
Not a bang.45Please respect copyright.PENANARiNwtRVEG3
Just a soft “thunk.”45Please respect copyright.PENANAhSTaIAA3Nd
Like someone landing gently on a metal railing.
Her Gotham instincts kicked in.45Please respect copyright.PENANAVbJFZho3a3
She grabbed a mirror, crouched low, slipped it between the curtain and the window, and checked the outside by reflection.45Please respect copyright.PENANAbht19tzl32
— She’d been practicing that move since she was twelve.45Please respect copyright.PENANAmmKpBu4NmD
Every Gotham kid knew better than to look directly into the dark.
Her eyes widened.
Nightwing.45Please respect copyright.PENANA0Uee65rFsq
She couldn’t mistake him.
— That black-and-blue suit.45Please respect copyright.PENANAlPXlO2T7uZ
The twin batons.45Please respect copyright.PENANARhHTS8bccK
That crouch.
She’d never been a fan, but she’d never expected him on her damn balcony either.
He was crouched on the railing, scanning the distance.
— His movement was smooth, breath quiet.45Please respect copyright.PENANAAEyJISW0rY
Like he was part of the night.
Her hand on the mirror was damp with sweat.45Please respect copyright.PENANA63sNE8WR4a
The scene didn’t belong to her life.
Then—he was gone.45Please respect copyright.PENANAcaoMkCP50X
Just leapt.45Please respect copyright.PENANAApkjzE71tf
Like a frame of film had been edited out.
Claire bolted upright and yanked the curtain open.45Please respect copyright.PENANA4MNTk6TZOr
Nightwing was already swinging away on his grappling line.
— Like a midnight pendulum.45Please respect copyright.PENANA3aaId0k8mV
Here, then not.
So... he passed by her balcony around eleven?
Had he always come by?
Had she been asleep, missing it every time?
— A blank spot appeared on her mental “loop chart.”45Please respect copyright.PENANAPXLkvv8pWd
He’d been here.45Please respect copyright.PENANAE3nCsR2GyI
And she’d never known.
She shut the curtain, stunned, dropped back onto the sofa.
What if her balcony was actually part of some secret patrol route?45Please respect copyright.PENANA2hsCv8lZcO
A rest stop?45Please respect copyright.PENANAN98Ld9Ajig
A transit point?
And she—owner of this tiny café—had never even noticed the rhythm of her own city’s nights.
45Please respect copyright.PENANAVTRSXevKAZ
But not now.45Please respect copyright.PENANAN5i9bfDHrv
Now wasn’t the time for that.
Tonight was about the reset.
— No distractions.45Please respect copyright.PENANA58c2AAllZX
No detours.
She tucked the “balcony incident” into a drawer in her mind.45Please respect copyright.PENANAVMkvT7u37N
One she’d open later.
Tonight’s mission: figure out when this world restarts.
Claire stayed on the couch and sipped her coffee.
— Bitter. Too bitter.45Please respect copyright.PENANAvh3XUZnxTt
She’d added way too much powder. On purpose.45Please respect copyright.PENANAMQZkKmr8FY
Her tongue was going numb.
Another sip.
She turned on the TV. A late-night talk show.
— Anything to stop thinking.45Please respect copyright.PENANA3Ml6aMIKFG
If she let her brain chew on itself too long, it would tie in knots.45Please respect copyright.PENANA5SbZn7St26
The host was still as loud and obnoxious as ever.45Please respect copyright.PENANA6J87NLkXv2
The laughter track made her want to throw the mug.
Fifth cup.45Please respect copyright.PENANALGShWIlac2
Her stomach felt swollen, like she’d swallowed an airbag.45Please respect copyright.PENANAnKZZIW09aG
Bitterness and acid mingled on her tongue.
Like she’d just drunk a bellyful of gunpowder.
Fuck.
— She didn’t say it out loud.45Please respect copyright.PENANAWktkNIOvxg
But it mushroomed in her mind like smoke from a silent bomb.
It was 4 a.m.
What now?
Was she supposed to stay up till sunrise?45Please respect copyright.PENANAlVOZmI1JVj
Was today not even part of the loop?45Please respect copyright.PENANAh07PXw8axx
What if this was the real Day Two?
The thought made her want to cry.45Please respect copyright.PENANAyExhMpSu78
Which immediately made her angry at herself for being dramatic.
Her head throbbed.
Maybe… maybe this would be the night that finally led into a real tomorrow.45Please respect copyright.PENANAM7x2u6ODEB
A new paper.45Please respect copyright.PENANAeOIKMC5wAR
A new customer.45Please respect copyright.PENANAxNViQJSEMe
A different damn bagel.
— She found herself fantasizing that the cursed newspaper would finally change.45Please respect copyright.PENANA0UPQDzusXq
Even if it still featured Nightwing’s butt, she’d settle for a different angle.
If that meant selling new bagels, she’d knead two extra batches as an offering.
The TV now sounded like a lullaby.45Please respect copyright.PENANASVLxv9Kmad
The laughter rose and fell like ocean waves.
For a moment, she wondered if the host was trying to hypnotize her.
No.45Please respect copyright.PENANAEv8BESuPPb
She couldn’t fall asleep.45Please respect copyright.PENANAdTnRwyjCxD
She’d made it from ten to four.45Please respect copyright.PENANAYZZCCc9EOU
She couldn’t give up now.
Claire shut her eyes on the sofa.45Please respect copyright.PENANAwvCmtKKomW
— Just for a second.45Please respect copyright.PENANA0chFqb4G4G
Her eyelids were dry.45Please respect copyright.PENANA5RQ3CwEZAg
She wasn’t sleeping, just… letting her corneas rest.
Next moment—
The jazz started.
Claire opened her eyes.45Please respect copyright.PENANAj7ZdCQlSxb
In bed.
Her head buzzed.45Please respect copyright.PENANA974V1DJmaw
Throat dry, like she’d inhaled ash.45Please respect copyright.PENANAGIM8MXToMl
The ceiling blurred for half a second.
Another day had begun.
— Same damn song.45Please respect copyright.PENANAi0a5Epl8zc
Same damn voice.45Please respect copyright.PENANAMb12Q8yIwq
That same punch-in-the-gut familiarity that made her want to throw the clock across the room.
She’d failed.
She stayed up all night.45Please respect copyright.PENANAN7PoRaWulJ
And still—nothing stuck.
She saw nothing.
But this world remembered everything.
45Please respect copyright.PENANAyDpqsZLraC