In a dim apartment tucked inside Blüdhaven’s quieter streets, the alarm clock rang right on schedule.51Please respect copyright.PENANAg5gmMJsTpM
Jazz seeped from the radio—one of those mellow, slightly dusty tunes that sound like they’ve been playing since the 1950s.
Claire blinked herself awake. Her brown eyes were still cloudy with sleep, but her body was already moving, out of habit more than intent.51Please respect copyright.PENANABWRuWU6muS
— Another morning, just as unremarkable as the last. Her limbs knew what to do. Her thoughts hadn’t caught up yet.
She got up slowly, pulled on her clothes, and watered the plant by the window.51Please respect copyright.PENANAO1w9KABr0c
— It looked like it had grown another inch. She always suspected it was secretly a cactus pretending to be something else.
By the time she reached the kitchen, the sky was barely awake—dark navy at the edges, with the faintest smear of light.51Please respect copyright.PENANA6PE4j79eee
— The sky felt like her: still hitting snooze, refusing to fully rise.51Please respect copyright.PENANAdiTgZYczDg
Claire never liked the moment daylight really took over. It was too loud. Too confident.
She ran a café. Small, slightly crooked, hiding in a forgettable alley.51Please respect copyright.PENANAQYyIfjTE0k
It used to be a secondhand store, left behind by her late aunt. Claire had turned it into something warm, something caffeinated.51Please respect copyright.PENANAEJiI8yo700
— Her aunt had... eccentric tastes. Claire never did figure out why she collected so many strange little things.
The only perk of the café’s location? It sat next to the Blüdhaven police precinct.51Please respect copyright.PENANA0mdvjkPGz8
Which meant she could afford to stay open until 7 p.m., unlike most shops that shut down by three.51Please respect copyright.PENANAESV92Wlq0u
— Cops might be sarcastic as hell, but at least they order fast.51Please respect copyright.PENANAn4ApGHw81Y
Way better than the afternoon crowd asking if she carried decaf-organic-soy-lattes while holding a shivering chihuahua.
When Claire took over the place, she didn’t know what to do with all the oddities left behind—prosthetic hands, glass eyeballs, and a music box that felt vaguely cursed.51Please respect copyright.PENANAJzHMXa8hJo
She shoved most of it upstairs into the second-floor room.51Please respect copyright.PENANAEUeHlZaWgu
— She never opened the music box. It always felt like it was waiting for her to mess something up.
She only used the first and third floors anyway.51Please respect copyright.PENANAPui6nu4veO
— Life had enough things she couldn’t control. As long as the building didn’t collapse, she wasn’t going to micromanage its haunted corners.
In the back kitchen, she pulled out yesterday’s dough and started shaping bagels.51Please respect copyright.PENANAOlxLySUcfq
The work rush would start soon.51Please respect copyright.PENANAtmE0Ctx0Oj
— Dough was gentle. Predictable. You give it time, temperature, attention—it behaves.51Please respect copyright.PENANAT2LmMfMzoh
People, not so much.
Claire felt oddly good that morning. Like maybe there’d be a steady stream of customers.51Please respect copyright.PENANAfWxZsBBbk2
— She was probably wrong. But a little self-deception before sunrise was better than starting the day already defeated.
She’d just finished lining up the bagels when the newspaper landed outside with a thud.51Please respect copyright.PENANAEBwHjJ5drx
She picked it up, glanced at the cover.
Nightwing.51Please respect copyright.PENANAXypiXKbeEV
Leaping mid-air, grinning like he knew the whole city was watching.51Please respect copyright.PENANA7twPosZSkx
Baton in hand. Camera focused squarely on his backside.
Claire…
— Rolled her eyes.51Please respect copyright.PENANAMCCsC6Uwpn
Did photographers forget faces existed? Or were asses genuinely more marketable now?
She tossed the paper onto the counter for whoever wanted it.51Please respect copyright.PENANA9sImXCpu9t
— Whatever. That ass might end up more popular than her bagels today.
The bell over the door rang. First customer of the day.
Claire smiled. A regular. Middle-aged cop, heading into work.51Please respect copyright.PENANAR5efCa05w1
— Always ordered the same thing: two black coffees. One for himself. The other? Never said. Claire never asked.
And just like that, the day began.
—--------------------------
The alarm rang in the dim apartment.51Please respect copyright.PENANAaJRIPMTam4
The jazz tune came on again—mellow, familiar, almost too familiar.
Claire opened her eyes, brown and heavy with sleep, and forced herself upright.
— She’d heard this before. Yesterday.51Please respect copyright.PENANAFEnJD9lyTG
That saxophone bend into the chorus, the beat that tripped just slightly before the downbeat—she could hum along.
Jazz wasn’t Top 40. No one plays the same track two days in a row.51Please respect copyright.PENANAWjpz5eZdnv
She frowned. Was it some jazz week promotion? A record label paying the station to loop the same song?
— No. This was lazy.51Please respect copyright.PENANAHgZ1BzhLWX
No edit, no transition. It picked up at the exact same spot as yesterday.
Claire sat up slowly. Her eyes were still half-closed, but her nerves were beginning to itch. Just enough to notice.
She dressed. Watered the window plant. Went downstairs.51Please respect copyright.PENANA29byQiGZd3
Same as always.
She glanced out the window. The sky looked about right for the season—late dawn, pale at the edges.51Please respect copyright.PENANA2yWhRbQZkZ
Nothing too weird. Not yet.
She stepped into the kitchen and pulled out the dough.51Please respect copyright.PENANAwwJ1ORPlcj
But stopped.
— That’s not right.
She remembered preparing chocolate dough last night. She wanted to make something sweet for Easter.51Please respect copyright.PENANA2cZxot1xDf
Added a pinch of cinnamon, too—just enough to give it depth.
But the dough in front of her? It was plain. Just like yesterday.
Maybe… she misremembered?51Please respect copyright.PENANAZ7IjpcZwTc
Claire shrugged it off and started baking anyway.51Please respect copyright.PENANA1mEknoKeQQ
— People get tired. Thoughts blur. Maybe she never made the chocolate batch at all.51Please respect copyright.PENANA7uo55Ps7IS
No point snapping at herself. Bagels don’t care.
The paper arrived.
She picked it up. Froze.
— That photo. That angle.51Please respect copyright.PENANAkI92XoarsR
That...ass.
She’d seen that picture.51Please respect copyright.PENANAAlXMkha0dF
Nightwing in midair, beaming like a rogue gymnast, baton in hand—camera lovingly focused on his backside.
Her temple twitched.
This was yesterday’s newspaper.
She remembered the exact thought from the morning before:51Please respect copyright.PENANAXMlo8Fu3nr
“Do photographers even remember to shoot faces?”
It floated up again, uninvited.
She flipped the paper to check the date.51Please respect copyright.PENANAOEprAanpkx
April 21st.
She looked toward the door, maybe to call after the delivery guy, but no one was there.51Please respect copyright.PENANAXPyLyeDkJz
Too late.
Still frowning, she set the paper on the counter and walked back toward the register.
The bell jingled. First customer.51Please respect copyright.PENANArdxqEfpBr4
Same man as yesterday.
Claire greeted him with a smile that didn’t quite reach her eyes.
“Hey Kyle,” she said. “You seen today’s paper?”
“Oh yeah,” he grinned. “That Nightwing kid again, huh?”
He glanced down at the cover and chuckled.
Claire swallowed her complaint about the mistaken delivery.51Please respect copyright.PENANAqysqeNYKeT
Maybe it was just a fluke.
She cleared her throat.51Please respect copyright.PENANAQvP6jOsBsj
“Kyle…what’s today’s date?”
Kyle blinked, then gave a little laugh. “April 21st, Claire. Easter Sunday.51Please respect copyright.PENANAH1TZ7wG0yc
And hey—Happy Easter!”
Claire’s eyes widened.
— April 21st.51Please respect copyright.PENANAxxYhB3hbQ4
She was sure that was yesterday.
She wasn’t the kind of person who forgot holidays. She’d even drawn a stupid bunny on a sticky note in the back kitchen.51Please respect copyright.PENANAGz9t0oJH6l
It was still there, taped to the counter. A reminder to push hot chocolate sales.
Her chest tightened.
Kyle was still smiling, saying something cheerful.51Please respect copyright.PENANAonlVSK536U
But she couldn’t hear him anymore.
Her mind had narrowed into one small, steady sentence:
— What the hell is going on?
51Please respect copyright.PENANAQdgJdxiLHI